I saw them last night at the Showbox in Seattle. I'd seen them about 3 years ago and was floored. I was even more floored this time around.
Total spectacle. I've seen hundreds of bands, but noone puts on a show like these guys. I've never seen anything remotely close to it. They are definitely a band for which it's all about the live show.
Sadly, with a 27 piece band, they can't afford to tour often. I believe this is the first time they've been in Seattle since I saw them back in December 2004.
I'd see them again tonight if I could. And tomorrow night, and the night after that, and the night after that, etc, etc
Total spectacle. I've seen hundreds of bands, but noone puts on a show like these guys. I've never seen anything remotely close to it. They are definitely a band for which it's all about the live show.
Sadly, with a 27 piece band, they can't afford to tour often. I believe this is the first time they've been in Seattle since I saw them back in December 2004.
I'd see them again tonight if I could. And tomorrow night, and the night after that, and the night after that, etc, etc
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Mon, July 16, 2007 - 8:05 PMI actually work at this place... www.goodrecords.com/ which is owned by the singer(Tim DeLaughter and his wife,along with their tour manager(so our bosses are in effect out of town)... -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Mon, July 16, 2007 - 10:02 PMTim DeLaughter is your boss... cool....
I am just so impressed with that band, especially seeing them live. I could see them over and over again. It's funny the polarity they inspire... people are just totally blown away by it, or they are frightened.
One friend of mine who saw them once said she thought it was impressive, but also a little creepy... she felt unnerved like she was watching Jim Jones or something... she thought it was cult-y. A co-worker of mine, who has not seen them, said the same thing, she looked a bit uneasy and said "they are kinda weird... like a cult" She actually thought it WAS a cult.
my friend knows that it isn't but the feeling of it being like one, the way the show is presented with Tim D being so much the focal point and standing up on the monitor lifting his hands to the sky and the rest of that HUGE band being basically non-entities (hey, if they changed those people out, I sure wouldn't know the difference, in fact, I'm pretty sure the harp player this time was different from the last time I saw them)... I mean, who knows any of those people's names, outside of the other band members and their friends? not me... he doesn't even introduce them... not all of them anyway. (he did introduce one of the drummers last night)... anyway, the impression of it being a cult, though she knows it isn't one, really creeps her out....
In fact, he actually caught my eye across the room, stared into my eyes and pointed right at me... and when I was telling her about it, my friend said "he was probably stealing your soul" *laughs* she wasn't serious, of course, but you get the idea
I just find it really interesting the reactions they seem to inspire -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Mon, July 16, 2007 - 10:06 PMso, you can answer a question I've always had.... is it pronounced like the word laughter? Or is it one of those "it's pronounced DeLofter" type names? just curious -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Tue, July 17, 2007 - 8:42 AM.....More like De Lotter...and they are not a cult...at all...a lot of the people in the band work as waiters and waitresses and what ever else they may do in the off time,they are just a bunch of people who happen to be in the same band.St.Vincent (who toured with Sufjan Stevens band)was in the band at one point,but had to be replaced because her album was coming out and she was starting her own tour.Tim is not quite as happy seeming all the time as the image and music may present.
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Tue, July 17, 2007 - 9:17 AMI'm seeing them tonight!
I've seen them 5 or 6 times now and find it really moving every time. I am a little cold on the new album, but it may grow on me, but it's almost irrelevant as far as the live shows go. -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Tue, July 17, 2007 - 10:45 AMfor those of you interested,here is a link to keep up with other fans,spree happenings,concert reports,discussions etc.
thepolyphonicspreeforum.com/ -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Tue, July 17, 2007 - 7:00 PMhey, I KNOW they aren't a cult... I'm just relaying some things I've heard from others... I find it an odd reaction and when I try to explain how ludicrous it is to think something like that, I get responses like "but they wear those matching robes" or "there are so many of them" or "that guy is so intense and he leans way out over the monitor and it's like he's preaching or something"
yep... that proves it! cult for sure
oh, and I never for a minute thought he was as happy all the time as he presents himself at the shows... generally, I think that only someone with a dark side could produce something like that...
sort of like stand up comedians tend to suffer from depression... not all of them, of course, but a very large percentage of them
he was pretty funny though, he mentioned Monty Hall and let's make a deal, then said, "i'm giving away my age" and, yeah, unless he is extraordinarily well-versed in pop culture, knowing about Let's Make a Deal puts him at 35 at a minimum LOL
I think they are great... the friends that went with me loved them too... one of them was a first-timer... a couple of them --who had seen the band before and like them--did complain about the "hard sell" for the merch table at the end of the show... and he did go on for at least 5 minutes... I was less forgiving than my friends were... that's a big group to tour with!!... but a couple of them were super super turned off when I mentioned how expensive it must be for them to tour with a group that big, they basically said something to the effect of "harumph!! they are on a major label! they aren't an indie band"
just FYI, I didn't have a problem with it myself, but it was for sure a very hard sell.... LOL and I don't remember him doing that the last time I saw them... in fact, I don't remember him talking as much generally the last time I saw them... he was really rattling on! personally, I enjoyed it
kinda miffed me that they didn't play 2000 Places though... at the end of the set, they did at least a snippet of almost every song on that album, and some they did the whole song... except for 2000 Places. And it was funny, because near the very end, there was a quiet moment and about 12 people around the room yelled "2000 Places" One person yelled "Hold Me Now" and it was that song that got played.
2000 Places is my fave song of theirs, so I would have liked to have heard it... and apparently I was far from alone. My guess is that the show is very pre-planned and choreographed and "Hold Me Now" was on the set list and so that's what they played. I didn't get a sense there was a whole lot of improvising going on. either that, or he just doesn't care to do the song anymore, because when all those people screamed it out, he said "I can't understand a word you people are saying" (though clearly he could) funny yes, but it was the one song I most wanted to hear
just wish they toured more often... this is the first time they've been up here since December 2004... and if selling more merchandise helps them do that, than okay by me! -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Tue, July 17, 2007 - 7:03 PMwhat i meant is I was MORE forgiving than my friends about the hard sell on the merch... though going as far as selling baby outfits and coffee mugs and arm patches isn't helping them shed the image some people have of them as a cult *laughs* ; -)
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Wed, July 18, 2007 - 8:07 AMWow. That was perhaps the best I've ever seen them. It sounds like they'd been having some trouble though the tour because he kept thanking us and saying, "We really needed this tonight." And they played for 2 1/2 hours!
I've heard interviews and stuff where he's talked about the economic reality of touring that many people. I actually think they don't do that well and we all know how much an artist gets from CD sales. I didn't mind the merch table speech because I think that they have been "just getting by" for a long time. And, besides, Tim and others were completely willing to stand at that table and chat and sign things as long as there was a crowd.
And I did notice the lack of "2000 Places", but as far as not improvising, we talked with the new cello player a little after the show and sheinsicated to us that they all watched him and that the show could change if he wanted. She said, specifically, "I was really worried at the end because it looked like he was about to start another one!"
She was really delightful and funny. -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Wed, July 18, 2007 - 8:20 PMwell, I'm beginning to think that the set list is much more choreographed/set-in-stone than I would like to believe... but I suppose with a group that big, I suppose it almost has to be. Especially considering that in many ways, it's very OBVIOUSLY choreographed... lol
they played for over 2 1/2 hours here... (they've played at least that long every time I've seen them) thanked us profusely, saying things very similar to what you have here... (then again, touring is rough, they probably really need it, so to speak, every night) Seattle was the show they played right before the one you saw... no shows inbetween...
it was their 7th birthday when they were here, and when he mentioned it, the crowd spontaneously burst into "happy birthday" that seemed to geniunely catch him off guard, from the way he reacted really didn't expect it.... at the end of the show they brought out a birthday cake.
their cover song was Nirvana.... Lithium, my all time fave Nirvana song... unbelievable!
i've heard they adjust their covers to the city and/or the occassion, so they might have done a different cover there...
sounds like the set is pretty "set" to me, but with some minor and very occassional variations...
Leaving out 2000 Places is just intentionally and perversely odd, I think... it's one of their most popular songs... it's the one that "hooked" me the first time I saw them live (which was the first time I'd ever heard them, period)
I didn't mind them pushing the merch.... (in fact, I bought some buttons for my friend who came with me to the show "sound unheard" ,and a patch for my jean jacket... if the shirts hadn't been so ugly, or had the hoodies not been $55, I might have gotten one of those two things, who knows?)
for me, if selling more merchandise means they can come up here more than once every 2 and 1/2 years, I'm all for it
but a couple of my friends sure did.... and, of course, it was the two who are in bands of their own... *laughs*
what I minded was that my friends wouldn't stick around so we could talk to them... and I had no other way to get home, so.... -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Thu, July 19, 2007 - 10:26 AMYou're probably right. It must require a pretty fixed routine to keep that many people in line.
Also, did you notice that he was a LOT less high than in the past? I've seen him come out looking like he would fall over and you can almost mark the peaks in his trip. This time, much more bright and articulate.
It's interesting that you say that about "2000 Places" being so popular as it speaks to people's different experiences of bands. I have another friend that was at your show and said the same thing, that it was like leaving out your biggest hit, but out here, it seemed pretty inconsequential. Had they left out "Soldier Girl" or "Light and Day" people would've gone nuts. I wonder if it's a regional thing?
He actually mentioned the "Happy Birthday" thing that you guys did! Nice job!
And yeah, we got "Lithium", too. -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Thu, July 19, 2007 - 6:05 PMI did notice he was much more articulate. I've never heard him talk so much.....
maybe your friend was also at the December 2004 secret show that I saw... "2000" was absolutely transfixing.... so maybe a lot of people got hooked at that show and that's why they all wanted to hear it again this time... not sure what the regional differences are. I mean none of those songs are truly "hits" in any way. So why do their fans up here like that song more than they do down your way? word of mouth maybe?
But they did at least a snippet of every other catchy/uptempo song on the album...except that one.... so it struck me as especially odd...
sounds like you down there got everything you wanted though...
he mentioned it, huh? how sweet of him. It must have caught him even more off-guard then I thought it did. *laughs* We Seattlites really are pretty special ; ) -
-
Re: The Polyphonic Spree
Thu, July 19, 2007 - 6:06 PMand, naturally, we got the super special "Lithium" with all the trimmings and a big pre-song speech... because, well, it is Seattle after all.... home of Nirvana and all things grunge
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-